A large dating app can show hundreds of profiles and still be almost useless. The catch is distance. A person listed as nearby may be in Orkney, on the Scottish mainland or technically within a broad radius that ignores the sea between you.
A Shetland dating site should work differently. It should help you distinguish between someone in Lerwick, someone commuting from Scalloway, a person based near Brae, and somebody living on Yell, Unst, Whalsay or another island where ferries shape the week. Those are not minor details. They decide whether meeting for coffee is easy, possible with planning, or unlikely to happen at all.
A smaller pool of genuinely reachable people is more useful than a crowded screen of distant profiles.
Be specific in your profile without giving away your address. Naming your general area, whether you drive, and how often you travel into Lerwick gives other members something practical to work with. If you work shifts, spend periods offshore or rotate through Sullom Voe, say so plainly. A changing schedule is manageable; a mysterious one creates doubt.
It also helps to state what “local” means to you. One person may happily travel between Lerwick and the South Mainland. Another may need someone on the same island because of family, work or ferry commitments. Neither is being difficult. They are being realistic.